Synology DiskStation DS918+ vs QNAP TS-453B: Which NAS should you buy?

Home server

Synology DS918+

Media centre

QNAP TS-453B

Synology opted to not include fancy IR receivers, remote controls, card readers, and other features in this NAS. Instead, the company focused on adding ii M.ii slots for maximum cache performance to allow you to run power-hungry applications and services.

$539 at Amazon

Pros

• User-friendly hot-swap trophy
• Two internal M.2 slots
• Excellent DMS Bone
• Solid build and blueprint

QNAP has a few handy features that brand the TS-453B an attractive NAS for media consumers. If you need to set a centralized hub to shop and stream all your media files, the QNAP NAS may exist the ameliorate option.

$459 at Amazon

Pros

• IR receiver and remote
• Card reader
• Pocket-sized Display
• Internal PCIe slot
• Improve value

Cons

• Not the best-looking NAS blueprint
• No bulldoze bay locks

Both the Synology DS918+ and QNAP TS-453B are excellent NAS solutions for the dwelling house and pocket-sized office. Both house similar internals, sport the aforementioned number of bays, and have nifty operating systems to boot. The choice is actually downwards to what you plan to do with the NAS, the slight price divergence, every bit well as brand loyalty.

Like specs

	DiskStation DS918+	QNAP TS-453B
CPU	Intel Celeron J3455 1.5GHz (2.3GHz burst)	Intel Celeron J3455 1.5GHz (2.3GHz flare-up)
RAM	Up to 8GB DDR3L	Upwardly to 8GB DDR3L
Bays	iv	4
Capacity	40TB	TB
Expansion back up	✓	✓
1000.2 Slots	two	-
Ports	2x GbE 2x USB iii.0 1x eSATA	2x GbE 5x USB three.0 1x PCIe 2.0 x2 slot
Menu Reader	-	✓
IR Receiver	-	✓
Dimensions	166 x 199 x 223 mm	168 x 170 ten 226 mm
Weight	ii.28kg (5.02lbs)	2.37 kg (5.22lbs)
PSU	100W	90W
Consumption	28.8W	30W

Intel powers everything

Both NAS models come rocking the same quad-cadre Intel Celeron J3455 processor, which isn't a slouch at 1.5GHz (able to burst up to 2.3GHz), although it doesn't compare to Core i5 or Core i7 for advanced processes. Y'all'll exist able to handle most tasks with either NAS, including the streaming and transcoding of media, but you may struggle at 4K and higher up.

For RAM, both back up up to 8GB of DDR3L retentivity and there are — of class — four bays available for hard drives. The number of ports is where things go a picayune interesting, with the DS918+ touting two Gigabit LAN ports (the aforementioned every bit QNAP), two USB 3.0, and a single external SATA port.

QNAP opted to go with five USB three.0 ports (including a front-facing USB Blazon-C connector), SD card reader, multiple jack inputs, merely no eSATA. The add-on of an IR receiver on the QNAP TS-453B with the bundled remote puts information technology in a better position as a media server.

If you don't plan on using a remote, the DS918+ is still a solid streaming box. The Os on the QNAP NAS is a great user feel and tin handle most tasks you throw at it, merely I have a personal soft spot for Synology'due south DMS in terms of pattern and functionality. Both solutions can handle automated app installation.

NAS Expansion

While QNP does offer a PCIe expansion card for adding two M.ii slots for super-fast SSD memory to be installed, Synology has this already included by default. This allows yous to add fast enshroud to take the pressure off your mechanical drives. On the flip side, with the add-on of a PCIe slot in the QNAP NAS, you can install a Wi-Fi carte du jour or some other extension.

The selection is really downwards to what y'all plan to do with the NAS, the slight toll difference, every bit well as make loyalty.

QNAP and Synology offer expansion units so you tin add more bays for the OS to use, which is handy for when y'all eventually run out of gratis infinite (especially in a RAID configuration). In order to admission the bays in the QNAP TS-453B, all you need to do is remove the front cover.

In the case of the DS918+, Synology has added a locking mechanism for each bay, requiring a key to unlock each one. This lock is mostly plastic, then you lot won't be able to forestall access to someone with a crowbar and some muscle, merely it may preclude the accidental release of a drive while in operation or dissuade someone from removing them.

The choice is yours

Information technology's an unfortunate case when you're looking for an answer and all we can come up with as a definitive conclusion is "the choice is yours." The reason backside this is both NAS models are pretty much identical in terms of operation and features equally a file storage motorcar. Where they differ is in cost and additional functionality.

Do yous want to start a abode media server and wish to salve some money? Go with the QNAP. Need to take advantage of M.2 slots and like the sound of securing your bays with lock and central? Synology is a solid pick.

Serious NAS performance

While both NAS models come up with the same Intel CPU, it's how Synology has approached the pattern of the DS918+ that makes it more preferable for those seeking to actually take advantage of maximum functioning with the inclusion of 2 M.2 slots.

Home server

Synology DS918+

Rocking advanced M.ii SSD slots

DiskStation Director is the Bone that powers Synology's range of NAS models. Information technology'due south ane of the best NAS platforms out at that place and when you throw reliable NAS drives into the mix with super-fast One thousand.two slots, you've got quite the speedy machine. The only drawback is the price and lack of inputs.

For all your media enjoyment

QNAP includes a remote command and then you lot know the TS452B is designed for media consumption. If you desire to store and stream your content to the big screen, this may well be the living room NAS for you.

Media middle

QNAP TS-453B

Ideal every bit a media server

The QNAP TS-453B looks to have been designed with media consumption in heed, especially when you consider the IR receiver, remote command, SD card reader, and a whole host of available ports on the rear. QNAP's software solution isn't quite as skilful as DSM, but it's non far off.

Nosotros may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.

Shop all the things

You lot Accept to use these hard drives for the ASUSTOR AS5304T NAS

The ASUSTOR AS5304T is a great NAS for homeowners, pocket-size offices and gamers. What makes it a compelling NAS to own is the four-bay setup, capable Intel processor, and killer OS. Yet, you demand to use the best hard drives to get the most out of this server.

Rich Edmonds

Rich Edmonds is a word conjurer at Windows Central, covering everything related to Windows, gaming, and hardware. He's been involved in applied science for more than a decade and knows a thing or two well-nigh the magic inside a device chassis. You can follow him over on Twitter at @RichEdmonds.

Source: https://www.windowscentral.com/synology-diskstation-ds918-vs-qnap-ts-453b

Posted by: stevensonablents.blogspot.com

Share this post